Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Book vs. Movie: The Fault in Our Stars

NOTE: I bet you guys have been waiting for this one, huh?

The Fault in Our Star's movie adaptation came out a couple of weeks ago, and I think you guys have had plenty of time to read the book and see the movie. So *SPOILERS AHEAD*

vs  

I really liked TFIOS. I think it's a heartbreaking, hilarious romance with valid points on love, life and relationships. 

Looking at the movie as a separate entity from the book, I think it's a pretty good movie. The actors were great with their characters (much better than I'd thought they'd be to be completely honest) and it was also a great mix of tears and laughter.

Differences:

- Hazel's friend Kaitlyn is not in the movie
- Hazel and Augustus have different ages than in the book
- Hazel's mom isn't obsessed about the minute holidays (which angered me because I found that really endearing)
- The last line of the book isn't the last line of the movie in one of the most ridiculous and infuriating moves I've ever seen. The whole "okay? okay." thing isn't THAT special and it's borderline cliche now. 
- A lot of scenes and aspects are cut from the book
  • Isaac and Hazel playing that voice-controlled game and ordering the character to "Hump the moist cave wall" which is the best scene in the book
  • Hazel letting a little girl try her oxygen tank at the airport
  • Caroline Mathers (Augustus's ex-girlfriend) is not really mentioned in the movie
  • Augustus's parents aren't really in the movie, and they don't have the dinner scene between the Waters and the Lancasters.
Personal things that irked me:

- I thought Van Houten was going to be more slobbish. Not just irritating and bitter.
- Isaac is relegated to the role of comic relief which pisses me off because his character is more than that. 
- Back to Caroline Mathers' role in the story: I think that adding in something more to add more depth to Gus's character would've been nice. I think his (admittedly terrible) relationship with her gave him more of a character back story than just "pretentious love interest that slowly reveals himself to be a sweetheart with cancer" because their story was interest. That being said, I'm glad that they didn't linger with Hazel's obsessive feelings over it, like Facebook-stalking Caroline after her death. 

Gus's Cancer: A Rant
Another thing that angers me is the fact that they cut out a lot of things with Gus's cancer, like the bed wetting and more moments of weakness like the vomiting and the general terribleness. And if they did mention it, it was verbally, not visually. It seemed like Josh Boone (the director) wanted to make this movie as friendly as possible in order for it to do better in the box office because Hazel's dramatic-but-not-gross cancer was heavily featured but Gus's "gross" cancer was hardly touched on. It just irritates me because John Green and the press and the people involved in the movie kept saying how true they kept it true to the book was just not that true. 

Which was better?

The book. Obviously. But, even though I have my complaints, it was probably one of the truer movie adaptations of a book I've seen. They just cut out things for time: not change things around like people have done before in other adaptations I've seen (1995 Scarlet Letter and My Sister's Keeper come to mind.) Overall, the movie is pretty true to the book. Plus, they added some great dialogue to the car-egging scene, which has my seal of approval because it was the perfect place for comedy. 

What are your thoughts? Leave them in the comments down below!

Owyn the Intern

P.S. I got to see a special screening of TFIOS and I tell the awesome story here!

16 comments:

  1. It paints itself into a contrived, cliché-ridden corner and, to get out of that, paints itself into yet another contrived, cliché-ridden corner, until it runs out of corners and becomes the formulaic, sentimental cancer movie you hoped it wouldn't.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The movie will be the stuff of truth and tragedy for some; for others, crafted schmaltz with an eye on the money.

    ReplyDelete
  3. parking permmits


    We take the frustration out of parking management for Apartments, Home Owners Associations, Condominiums, Townhouses Co-ops, and other parking areas. www.Webparkingsoftware.com has reinvented how parking management should be done and more information then contact us :

    CBT SOLUTIONS, INC.
    23785 El Toro Road Suite 122
    Lake Forest, CA 92630
    call : 1-855-228-0411

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly that love and read more on this topic.
    instagram followers

    ReplyDelete

  5. Learn to Barter

    Author, Entrepreneur and Statesman Michael J. Sparks shares his advice and wisdom on how to Barter. Bartering has been around since the beginning of man, yet practiced by few. Learn to Barter & 21 Ways to Increase your Income will Teach you to do More with Less. In these Tough Times & our Economy on the brink of collapse, owing China & other Countries Trillions of dollars, Bartering can possibly even save & protect your Life and more information then visit: http://streetsmarts360.com

    Contact Us Now:
    Smyrna, Tennessee USA
    Call: 615-525-3198

    ReplyDelete

  6. book of nursery rhymes


    Hi everyone! Inspirational Nursery Rhymes authors Todd and Jackie Courtney here. We recently launched our first edition of Inspirational Nursery Rhymes board books and we’re looking for feedback! We have set aside a small stock of board books to give to reviewers in exchange for an honest review via your website, blog, forum, or social media.
    We are very excited about this series of children’s books and would like to get your input on what you liked or didn’t like as well as what you’d like to see incorporated into future books. Please fill out the form below and we will get you a review copy right away! http://www.inspirationalnurseryrhymes.com/request-a-review-copy/

    ReplyDelete
  7. I’d recommend The Fault in Our Stars to everyone. It reminds you how precious life is, and how lucky we are to be healthy. It reminds you to take every opportunity you get, and I love that about it. I’m sure The Fault in Our Stars will stay with me for a long time, and I’d be tempted to revisit it again in the future if I feel like I’m forgetting.

    ReplyDelete
  8. used to offer not only to send out messages immediately after death, but to send them also in predesignated dates in the futurefacebook

    ReplyDelete
  9. Although the main reason for creating these groups was to foster a collaborative environment for classroom teachers, I also createdfacebook

    ReplyDelete
  10. I could be wrong. It's not easy getting this kind of information without calling a live person at YouTube!facebook

    ReplyDelete
  11. I’d recommend The Fault in Our Stars to everyone. It reminds you how precious life is, and how lucky we are to be healthy. It reminds you to take every opportunity you get, and I love that about it. I’m sure The Fault in Our Stars will stay with me for a long time, and I’d be tempted to revisit it again in the future if I feel like I’m forgetting.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I like both. The movie was well done and faithful to the spirit of the book. It isn't my favorite of his books, but I do love it. Several of my students were hardcore fans of the book, and they were pleased with the movie. I wanted to say more, but I can't put it into words. I just keep thinking about Esther Earl. She's been on my mind since I went to see the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  13. It has been extremely difficult to locate a bookstore that carries an episcopal hymnal that I can use.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I hope everyone can read this with an open mind and an open heart. Then, reach out to the patients and survivors in your communities. They are wise beyond their years, funny, brave and inspiring.

    Marlene
    Informative URL for Ketchikan Fishing

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for posting this... If you ask me though There isnt anything wrong with buying a couple thousand fake followers every now and then. Even some of the most famous celebs have been caught getting millions of botted followers from sites like Wizish | Explode on Social Media!. Who cares?

    ReplyDelete

  16. round rock web design
    web design round rock
    local web design round rock


    We're your local web design company in Round Rock & Austin, creating effective website designs that engages with your target audience & increases leads & sales. Call me >>Phone: 512-994-0191

    ReplyDelete